What Does the Bible Say About Alcohol?

The complicated history of American Christianity and the fruit of the vine
What Does the Bible Say About Alcohol?

"Jesus couldn’t have made wine at the wedding at Cana.” The old man was adamant. “He couldn’t have made wine because making wine would be a sin. Jesus never sinned.” He turned and walked out of the church, Bible under his arm, without giving my dad—the pastor—a chance to reply.

Sin or Blessing?

It’s a perfect example of circular reasoning, or “assuming the premise.” Making wine is sinful; Jesus couldn’t have sinned, and, therefore, Jesus could not have made wine.

My dad had been trying to explain that the Greek word for the stuff Jesus made in John 2 was the same as the word for the stuff Paul tells the church not to get drunk on in Ephesians 5:18, and it was all a bit much for the man to take in.

His concern, if not his logic, was reasonable. If you’ve been raised to regard wine as inherently sinful, the Bible can be disturbing reading. Jesus makes wine and serves wine; he says that wine is the new covenant in his very blood. The psalmist praises wine as that which gladdens a person’s heart (Psalm 104:14–15), and the Teacher urges the reader to drink wine with gladness, insisting that God approves (Ecclesiastes 9:7).

Biblical warnings about wine simply underline the fact that what we’re talking about is, in fact, wine.

No small measure of ink has been spilled in an attempt to blot out the Bible’s embarrassing oenophilia; The Temperance Bible-Commentary (1868) is but one example of the volumes that have been written (and are probably still being written) to correct this perceived flaw. These writings generally go to great and tedious lengths to demonstrate that wherever the Bible reads “wine,” we are to understand it to mean “grape juice,” or, bizarrely, “raisin paste” (which sounds more like a cookie filling, or a laxative, than a beverage), or else to argue that when the Bible mentions “wine,” it’s referring to something so diluted as to be essentially non-intoxicating.

Subscriber access onlyYou have reached the end of this Article Preview
To continue reading, join now for free and get complete access.
orJoin Now for Free
Free CT Women Newsletter

Sign up today for our weekly newsletter: Marriage & Family Newsletter. CT's weekly newsletter to help women grow their marriage and family relationships through biblical principles.

Alcohol; Bible; Blessings; Jesus Christ; Scripture; Sin
Today's Christian Woman, April 1, 2015
Posted April 1, 2015

Read These Next


For Further StudyFor Further StudyDownloadable resources to go deeper

Comments

Join in the conversation on Facebook or Twitter

May 25

Follow Us

More Newsletters

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
RSS
Email